top of page
  • 812living

Homeowners Insurance Hacks: 5 Proven Tips to Tame Rising Premiums

Updated: Feb 1

Owning a home in Indiana is a dream for many, but soaring homeowners insurance costs are throwing a wrench in those aspirations. As a realtor, I see firsthand how rising premiums squeeze budgets and challenge first-time buyers. Let's unpack the numbers, analyze the impact, and equip Hoosier homeowners with tips to tame the insurance beast.

The Harsh Reality

Indiana hasn't escaped the national trend of increasing homeowners insurance premiums. According to the Insurance Information Institute, homeowners in the Hoosier state saw an average cost hike of 15% between 2021 and 2023. That translates to an extra $225 per year for the average Hoosier home insured for $200,000, a significant chunk of change in anyone's book.

Why the Pain?

Several factors are fueling the fire:

  • Inflation: The rising cost of everything, from construction materials to labor, impacts rebuilding costs, ultimately reflected in your premiums.

  • Weather Woes: Indiana's vulnerability to severe weather events like hailstorms and tornadoes makes insurers increasingly cautious, translating to higher risk-based premiums.

  • National Trends: National reinsurance costs, which help insurers manage large claims, have risen, impacting premiums across the board.

Impact on Affordability

This isn't just a sticker shock for existing homeowners; it's a hurdle for aspiring buyers. Higher premiums factor into mortgage calculations, leaving less room for the purchase price, potentially pricing some out of the market entirely.

Fighting Back

Don't despair, Hoosiers! Here are some ways to minimize the bite of your homeowners insurance:

  1. Shop Around: Get quotes from multiple insurers. Rates can vary significantly, so don't just stick with your current provider. Local Indiana-based carriers may offer competitive rates compared to national giants.

  2. Increase Your Deductible: A higher deductible means a lower premium. Weigh the trade-off: can you handle a larger out-of-pocket expense if something happens?

  3. Bundle Policies: Combining homeowners with auto or other insurance policies with the same provider often earns you a discount.

  4. Invest in Home Improvements: Upgrades like storm-resistant roof shingles or security systems can lower your risk profile and lead to premium reductions.

  5. Maintain Your Home: Regular upkeep and maintenance demonstrate to insurers that you're proactive, potentially earning you a more favorable rate.

Stay Informed

Because insurance premiums seem to be changing rapidly, it's important that you stay on top of your personal policies and coverages:

  • Review your policy annually: As your home's value or your needs change, your policy might need adjustments. Regularly review and update your coverage accordingly.

  • Consider add-ons: You can customize your policy with optional coverages like valuable items insurance, identity theft protection, or service contracts for appliances or home systems.

  • Consult a professional: If you have questions or concerns, don't hesitate to consult with an insurance agent or broker. They can help you assess your needs and find the best coverage for your situation.

  • Insurance is about tradeoffs: The more risk you are willing to cover out of your own pocket, the cheaper your insurance premium should be, and vice versa. So by reviewing and adjusting each coverage within your polices, you can customize the policy for your preferred risk and cost levels.

At the 812 Living Group, we maintain a list of trusted local professionals we call our MVPs (Most Valuable Providers) If you are looking for a trusted local Insurance Professional who can give you a second opinion on your insurance coverages and costs, email us at and we'll recommend some to you.

By staying informed and proactive, Indiana homeowners can navigate the world of homeowners insurance confidently and ensure their most valuable asset is well-protected.


Rising insurance costs are a challenge, but by being proactive and informed, Hoosier homeowners can navigate this tide and keep their homeownership dreams afloat. As your local realtor, I'm here to help you navigate the homebuying process, including understanding insurance implications. Get in touch, and let's work together to make your Indiana homeownership dream a reality, even in the face of rising premiums.

Together, we can all weather the storm!


If you have questions about buying or selling a home in Southern Indiana or you'd like to know what your house is worth in the current market, message us at


> 812 Living Group - Helping turn your dream, into your address <

33 views0 comments


Contact Us

bottom of page